Discussion Forum
This is a forum to discuss the gray areas of the English language for which you would not find answers easily in dictionaries or other reference books.
Do You Have a Question?
Latest Posts : Punctuation and Mechanics
I wrote, “I have two sons, Bill and Ben.”
An editor said that the comma should be a colon. That opinion is backed up by various style guides which say a list (and presumably “Bill and Ben” is a list) should be preceded by a colon. I still feel that a colon is unnecessary, though I probably would use a colon if I had five sons not two. Would I use a colon with three sons? I’m not sure.
Had I written, “I have two sons, Bill and Ben, both in their twenties” there would surely be no question of a colon being required. It seems odd to me that omitting the final phrase, “both in their twenties” forces the first comma to become a colon.
I would be interested in others’ views.
Which of the follow is correct?
- CAYA stands for “come as you are.”
- “CAYA” stands for “come as you are.”
I am not referring to the Nirvana song, so I assume that capitalization is not necessary when spelling out what the initialism stands for.
If a city and state (and full date) start a sentence in possessive form, would you consider the punctuation correct in the following three examples?
- Frankfort, Kentucky’s crime rate has increased.
- Paris, France’s breathtaking sights left us in a state of raptures.
- September 11, 2001’s tragic events will forever be indelibly etched in the minds of everyone.
Please, no recasts.
When including a complete sentence in parentheses, what are the rules? For example, someone just sent me this in an email:
“I always change some of the readings from semester to semester (for example, I am trying out the book on migration for the first time this semester and am not sure if I will keep it in the Fall).”
But I could just as easily see it written this way:
“I always change some of the readings from semester to semester. (For example, I am trying out the book on migration for the first time this semester and am not sure if I will keep it in the Fall.)”
Are both acceptable? Is one preferred?
When making a list of the very same name of something, is it proper english to use one quotation mark in place of the same name or word after writing it a couple of times down the list? I can’t seem to find anything on it.
Which ending punctuation sequence is correct for a question dialogue sentence containing a quotation within it?
a. ”Does the menu say, ‘no substitutions?’” asked Jo.
or
b. ”Does the menu say, ‘no substitutions’?” asked Jo.
My friend is sending an invitation, and she is using the date of:
January, 16th 2016
Is this technically correct, or at a minimum not considered barbaric? Where should the comma be?
In a sentence, there is the name of a company followed by an abbreviation, the initials of the company, in parentheses. The company name is a possessive in this sentence. Where does the apostrophe go? I want to know how this would work, as I am having trouble finding anything but advice to restructure the sentence, and I would like an answer that gives me what to do with the sentence as it stands.
Example: This policy sets a standard for determining access to Introspective Illusions (II) resources.
Would it be Introspective Illusions’ (II’s) or Introspective Illusions’ (II) or some other construction?
Should a rhetorical question end with a question mark?
I have a question about “;” and “—” as used in sentence structure. I prefer using — i.e. “He did not expect to meet anyone—the house had been empty for years—and was surprised to hear whistling from the upper floor.”
Now, as I wrote a line in my story, as sentence ran away from me and I ended up using a ; at the end, as well as the — and I got the feeling that maybe it had to be one or the other all the way through and not a mix. Anyway, the sentence (racial slur warning)
Rod had not let her buy the beer herself at first—not until father had gone down there and cleared up some misconceptions from that sneaky pool-digger—and hadn’t that been a fun day to be alive; now he just gave her sympathetic looks whenever she came to get beer for her father.
So, in such a sentence, is it right to use both the “—” and the “;”? I can always rebuild it, but it felt right to me somehow, even though I got uncertain about if it would sting in the eyes of others.
Latest Comments
Past perfect with until
- devidjohan
- February 21, 2025, 11:06am
She **had waited** until the illustrator completed the drawings before publishing her book. The author, using **kids book writing services**, ensured the story was engaging and visually appealing. She **had not realized** its impact until parents and children praised its creativity and storytelling after its release.
Initialisms and Quotation Marks
- burekus5231
- February 20, 2025, 3:14am
I recently discovered this site, and I’ve been thoroughly impressed. The layout is simple yet effective, making it easy to browse through the vast game selection. What I love most is the transparency of the rules and the straightforward bonus system. Every game I’ve tried so far has been smooth, and it’s refreshing to play on a platform that values the player’s experience. If you're in United Kingdom and searching for a reliable casino experience, give rollino a try – you won’t be disappointed.
“I have two sons, Bill and Ben”: comma or colon?
- andrewsinn
- February 18, 2025, 10:35pm
I can see how this punctuation dilemma might cause some confusion. When it comes to short lists, like naming two sons, a comma seems more natural, especially since it doesn’t feel like a complete formal list. But for longer lists or when more clarity is needed, such as in legal or formal contexts, using a colon might make sense. It’s interesting to see different perspectives on this! By the way, if you're looking for a fun and exciting way to unwind, you might want to check out https://slotier.com/. With a great selection of games and rewarding bonuses, it's the perfect way to relax after a deep dive into punctuation!
“by the time”
- taleshka
- February 12, 2025, 12:54pm
If I look at this sentence: "By the time he arrived, the lesson had finished". I wonder if it would be enough just to say "the lesson finished", as the time expression of "by the time" seems to clearly indicate what happened first. Am I right or is it 100% necessary to use Past Perfect with the expression?
Treatment of abbreviations and superscript items in full capital case
- smithcarrie96
- February 12, 2025, 7:35am
Need help with your management assignments? With Management Assignment Help services, you can reach out to the experienced writers for educational advice. From business strategies to case studies, we provide well researched and delivered assignments before the deadline.
Walking Heavens
- Devis1
- February 11, 2025, 3:18pm
When I was still new to nursing, I had a hard time figuring out how to write an essay. I had no experience and the topic was complex. Then I found the site https://nursingwriting.org/nursing-assignment/ and the guys helped me every step of the way. The essay turned out great, with the correct use of terms and no mistakes. Now, when I have difficulties with writing, this is where I will turn!
"badly miscalculated" — double negatives?
- Devis1
- February 10, 2025, 10:04pm
"badly miscalculated" — double negatives?
- Devis1
- February 10, 2025, 10:03pm
I needed to use rare and relevant research, but finding it in the library was too difficult. I decided to turn to the site best nursing writing services , and they found all the necessary materials for me. This saved a lot of time and allowed me to focus on other important tasks. I am very happy with the result and recommend the site to everyone!
“I have two sons, Bill and Ben”: comma or colon?
- alexseen
- February 5, 2025, 1:26pm
asd
Past perfect with until
She **had waited** until the illustrator completed the drawings before publishing her book. The author, using **kids book writing services**, https://bookspublishinghelp.com/kids-book-writing-services ensured the story was engaging and visually appealing. She **had not realized** its impact until parents and children praised its creativity and storytelling after its release.