Idea Vs. Ideal
Why do people say they have an Ideal instead of an Idea, which is correct?
Your Pain Is Our Pleasure
24-Hour Proofreading Service—We proofread your Google Docs or Microsoft Word files. We hate grammatical errors with a passion. Learn More
Your Pain Is Our Pleasure
24-Hour Proofreading Service—We proofread your Google Docs or Microsoft Word files. We hate grammatical errors with a passion. Learn More
I've heard a few people use 'Ideal' and never use the word 'Idea.' So, it must be regional ( I live in the South.)
I was wondering what the correct usage was, but something really threw me for a loop:
There is a line of feminine hygiene products that used to have the name 'Dry Idea' as the brand name.
Now I am seeing the same product being marketed as 'Dry Ideal.'
I thought 'Dry Ideal' sounded really weird for such an item and I wonder what prompted their marketing department to change it.
Jenn1 Aug-01-2006
9 votes Permalink Report Abuse
One may encounter problems in Bristol, where it is customary to add an L to words ending in a vowel.
mike7 Jun-13-2006
4 votes Permalink Report Abuse
It really bugs me when people use the words "ideal" and "idea" wrong. With some people no matter how many times you correct them, they still use it wrong. We have an employee that ALWAYS says ideal instead of idea.
Amy_ Jun-09-2006
17 votes Permalink Report Abuse
I don't mean to sound like I am making fun of you Dominic, but I have never heard of a speech impediment similar to yours. Do you say all "ea" sounds with an "l" on the end?
ReverendDave Apr-03-2006
3 votes Permalink Report Abuse
hahah, i used to have a teacher that would always say "ideal" in place of the word idea. We would sit in class and count how many times she would say it. Man, was she dumb.
Steve1 Mar-13-2006
18 votes Permalink Report Abuse
"I have an idea" and "I have an ideal" are both correct sentences. But the meanings are quite different.
bubbha Feb-18-2006
11 votes Permalink Report Abuse
I, too, have never heard ideal in place of idea. I can tell you that as a striving and moral person I do have ideals, and in some contexts might stress one particular one by saying I have an ideal. Is it possible that this is what you have encountered?
porsche Oct-21-2005
5 votes Permalink Report Abuse
I have never heard anyone use the word ideal in place of idea. if you have you must have spoken to some dumb people!
Theresa Oct-02-2005
19 votes Permalink Report Abuse
CORRECT (noun):
"I have an ideal; that people be treated equally."
CORRECT (adjective):
"I have an ideal situation."
INCORRECT (noun):
"I have an ideal: let's go to White Castle!"
good Oct-01-2005
34 votes Permalink Report Abuse
I've got a speech impediment and I can't say idea, it always comes out with the 'l' sound at the end. Of course I always though everyone else was saying ideal too so I didn't realize the difference until my freshman year at college when a proffesor pointed out I was using the wrong word. Mikahbot has the right definitions
Dominic1 Sep-30-2005
11 votes Permalink Report Abuse
Only illiterate people say ideal in place of idea.
Smart_Guy Sep-29-2005
70 votes Permalink Report Abuse
I've heard it only from one person, but I heard it consistently from them, and they were decidedly using "ideal" in place of "idea"
Jeremy2 Sep-29-2005
29 votes Permalink Report Abuse
Haven't heard ideal, but I have sometimes heard idear, which I always react to when I hear it.
slemmet1 Sep-29-2005
12 votes Permalink Report Abuse
i hear it alot.. but i live in the south and people talk funny. i always assumed ideal was wrong when i heard people say it but never knew for sure. i have always said idea.
ahatter Sep-29-2005
29 votes Permalink Report Abuse
Uh...okay. Saying that something is ideal means that whatever the subject is, it's perfect or is close to perfection. Example: Having a mustang [car] is ideal. [I think I was sort of right...] Idea is something that gets invented in your head, like "Ooh, I got an idea! Let's go to a movie!" You get it? Idea and Ideal are similar, but are used in different contexts. Idea is a noun, and ideal is more of an adjective.
Mikahbot Sep-29-2005
55 votes Permalink Report Abuse
I have not heard anyone use the word ideal in place of idea, however it does not surprise me. Prehaps they mistake the two completely different words to mean the same thing, but think that Ideal is just a more educated form of the word idea. Where would they get such an ideal? ;)
Dylan_M. Sep-28-2005
20 votes Permalink Report Abuse