Your Pain Is Our Pleasure
24-Hour Proofreading Service—We proofread your Google Docs or Microsoft Word files. We hate grammatical errors with passion. Learn More
December 29, 2009
Total number of comments
Total number of votes received
Thank you to everyone for the comprehensive treatment of my question. It’s more than I expected!
I’d like some clarification from DC or anyone who might elaborate on DC’s explanation. I think DC suggests testing the sentence by simplifying it to ascertain whether the objective or subjective pronoun fits. His shortened examples work well: “Serious gardeners use organic fertilizer or “My wife and I use organic fertilizer.” However, what if the husband/subject of the original sentence refers to himself only?:“Serious gardeners like me/myself/I always use organic fertilizer.”
DC says that “Serious gardeners” is subjective, so “like me/myself/I” must be, also. He says “me/myself” are not subjective, so they’re wrong. If I delete “me/myself” and simplify the sentence per his suggestion, then I get the following:
“Serious gardeners always use organic fertilizer” or“I always use organic fertilizer” … therefore …“Serious gardeners like I always use organic fertilizer.” (This sounds odd.)
What have I done wrong here? Is “like I” correct here?
Douglas, Steve, and Chris,Thank you ever so much for the helpful responses. I could swear that the increasing popularity of migraine-inducing expressions such as the one Chris mentioned, "Please return this form to the secretary or myself" is responsible for my oblivion. "Theirselves" are at fault! :-) Myself is signing off,Helen :-)
©2018 CYCLE Interactive, LLC.All Rights Reserved.